Notebook

United Methodists in the Pew data, 2007 to 2024: what really changed, and which trends you cannot trust

Notebook · Published 2026-11-21

A small white wooden church with a steeple and green roof under a blue sky with clouds, surrounded by grass
St. Catharine United Methodist Church in Linn County, Missouri. Photo: Binx1966, CC0.

The five practices framework was born in a United Methodist setting, and the denomination has lived through its hardest decade in recent memory: a wave of congregations leaving between 2019 and 2023, then a General Conference in 2024 that changed church law on sexuality. What does survey data say about the people who still call themselves United Methodists? We read Pew Research Center's three Religious Landscape Studies (2007, 2014 and 2023-24) practice by practice, and kept only the comparisons that Pew says are sound.

Key figures

The question, and why it matters now

Membership totals are the figure most often quoted about the denomination, and the least informative. The church's own news service has explained why membership numbers are hard to trust: rolls are cleaned irregularly, and one finance official quoted there considers attendance "a more reliable metric of the activity of a church." Survey data adds something rolls cannot: what members actually do and believe. Pew's study is the largest such source, with 1,318 United Methodist respondents in 2023-24, 1,637 in 2014 and 2,239 in 2007.

The timing matters too. In May 2024 delegates voted 692-51 to remove the ban on gay clergy, a vote that, as CBS News reported from the Associated Press, came after "the departure of one-quarter of the U.S. churches within the UMC." The 2023-24 survey was fielded between July 2023 and March 2024, at the end of that exodus and just before the vote: it is the first portrait of the denomination that remained.

A warning before reading any trend

The 2007 and 2014 studies were telephone surveys. The 2023-24 study was mostly answered online or on paper, and Pew ran a separate telephone "bridge study" to test which questions changed with the mode alone. Its appendix on comparing results sorts questions into three groups: green (safe to compare), yellow (compare with caution) and red (do not compare). Religious attendance and scripture reading are red: people report going to church more often when talking to an interviewer. That is why the weekly attendance figure for United Methodists, 27% in 2023-24 against 44% in 2014, must not be read as a collapse. Pew had already shown in a 2021 analysis of survey modes how much the way a question is asked shapes the answer.

United Methodists in Pew Research Center surveys, 2007, 2014 and 2023-24 Share of self-identified United Methodist adults: pray daily 59, 62, 48 percent; absolutely certain God exists 78, 71, 64; aged 65 or older 26, 32, 47; homosexuality should be accepted 51, 60, 68; prayer or scripture group weekly 19, 25, 11. 2007 2014 2023-24 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% Pray at least daily 59 62 48 Absolutely certain God exists 78 71 64 Aged 65 or older 26 32 47 Say homosexuality should be accepted * 51 60 68 Prayer or scripture group weekly * 19 25 11
Share of self-identified United Methodist adults. Asterisk: "yellow" question, to be compared cautiously according to Pew. Data: Pew Research Center, Religious Landscape Studies 2007, 2014, 2023-24. Chart: Vine & Lintel, free to reuse with a link to this page.

Practice by practice

Passionate worship: one snapshot, no trend

In 2023-24, 27% of United Methodists say they attend at least weekly, 12% once or twice a month, 24% a few times a year and 36% seldom or never. Because the question is red, the honest reading is a snapshot: a little over a quarter of those who claim the name are in a pew most weeks. The denomination's own count points the same way. The church's statistical summary gives an average weekly attendance of 1,425,352 in person for the U.S. in 2022, about 26% of the 5,424,043 members on the rolls, plus 1,715,890 online. Two very different methods, one survey and one headcount, land within a point of each other. For more on what worship asks of a congregation, see our page on passionate worship.

Intentional faith development: prayer and small groups have thinned

Daily prayer is a green question, so this decline is real: 59% of United Methodists prayed at least daily in 2007, 62% in 2014, 48% in 2023-24. Taking part in a prayer or scripture-study group at least weekly fell from 25% to 11% since 2014. That question is yellow: Pew concludes that weekly participation in such groups has declined across the population, "although not necessarily by the full amount of the difference seen in results." The direction is clear even if the size is not. Weekly scripture reading (20% in 2023-24) is red and has no usable trend. Small groups are the backbone of intentional faith development; these numbers suggest that is where congregations have most to rebuild.

Belief: steady at the core, less certain at the edge

Nearly all United Methodists still believe in God or a universal spirit, but the share who are absolutely certain fell from 78% in 2007 to 71% in 2014 and 64% in 2023-24, a comparison Pew rates as safe. The share saying religion is "very important" in their lives dropped from 61% to 41%, but Pew flags that question as yellow: it scores lower in the new survey even against Pew's own other polls, partly because of where it sits in the questionnaire.

Radical hospitality: an older church, a changed outlook

The age profile is the starkest result. Almost half of United Methodists are now 65 or older (47%), up from a quarter in 2007; 6% are aged 18 to 29, and only 16% have children under 18 at home, against 28% in 2007. Meanwhile the share saying homosexuality should be accepted by society rose from 51% to 60% to 68%, the part of that question Pew says can be compared. Departures of mostly conservative congregations probably explain part of this shift: the survey describes who remained, not how individuals changed their minds. For a congregation, the practical question is the one at the heart of radical hospitality: who is missing from the room, and what would it take to welcome them?

The full table

Measure (United Methodist adults)200720142023-24Pew comparability
Pray at least daily59%62%48%green
Believe in God, absolutely certain78%71%64%yellow (this answer comparable)
Religion very important59%61%41%yellow
Prayer or scripture group at least weekly19%25%11%yellow
Homosexuality should be accepted51%60%68%yellow (this answer comparable)
Aged 65 or older26%32%47%demographic
Aged 18 to 2910%9%6%demographic
Attend services at least weekly43%44%27%red: do not compare
Read scripture at least weekly33%39%20%red: do not compare

What this means for a church council

The wider context is less gloomy than these figures suggest: Pew's headline finding is that the decline of Christianity in the U.S. has slowed and may have levelled off, with 62% of adults identifying as Christian, roughly stable since 2019.

Methodology

Figures for United Methodists come from the tables of Pew Research Center's denomination profile (Religious Landscape Study fielded 17 July 2023 to 4 March 2024; earlier studies in 2007 and 2014), read on 21 November 2026. Comparability labels follow Pew's Appendix A; where only one answer of a yellow question is comparable, we show that answer only. "United Methodist" means people who identify with the denomination in the survey, not members on church rolls. Denominational figures (members, churches, attendance) are the 2022 U.S. jurisdictional figures published by United Methodist Communications from reports to the General Commission on Finance and Administration; the same page gives a current worldwide membership of about 11,299,000 from a November 2025 report. We do not republish Pew's data files; the table above quotes the published percentages. The chart is free to reuse with a link to this page. Updated 21 November 2026.

Sources